Analysis of State Responsibility for Health Rights in Indonesia: Integrating Legal Positivism and Justice Theory
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.59188/eduvest.v5i12.52613Keywords:
theory of justice, legal positivism, state responsibilityAbstract
This research examines the legal and moral dimensions of the state's responsibility for the right to health in Indonesia by synthesizing legal positivism and contemporary theories of justice. Focusing on Law No. 17 of 2023 on Health and the National Health Insurance scheme (Jaminan Kesehatan Nasional, JKN), the research argues that formal legal validity alone is insufficient to discharge the state’s constitutional obligations. While Indonesia has constructed a procedurally coherent health law framework that satisfies positivist criteria of legality, significant gaps remain in the realization of substantive justice, particularly for disadvantaged populations. By juxtaposing H.L.A. Hart’s conception of legal validity with John Rawls’s theory of justice as fairness, this study demonstrates that the legitimacy of health law must be assessed not only by its formal pedigree but also by its distributive consequences. The research concludes that state responsibility for health rights requires an integrated approach in which legal positivism is complemented—and normatively corrected—by justice-based evaluation, thereby proposing a dual-threshold conception of state responsibility in health law that distinguishes legal validity from normative legitimacy through doctrinal analysis and normative institutional evaluation. This study conceptually reframes state responsibility for social rights as a dual-threshold structure in which formal legality constitutes a necessary condition of obligation, while distributive justice operates as an independent condition of legitimacy.
References
Agustina, R., Dartanto, T., Sitompul, R., Susiloretni, K. A., Suparmi, Achadi, E. L., Taher, A., Wirawan, F., Sungkar, S., Sudarmono, P., Shankar, A. H., & Thabrany, H. (2019). Universal health coverage in Indonesia: Concept, progress, and challenges. The Lancet, 393(10166), 75–102. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0140-6736(18)31647-7
Chapman, A. R. (2016). Global health, human rights and the challenge of neoliberal policies. Cambridge University Press.
Ferraz, O. L. M. (2020). Health inequalities, rights, and courts: Bringing the bottom up. Health and Human Rights, 22(2), 139–150.
Finnis, J. (2011). Natural law and natural rights (2nd ed.). Oxford University Press.
Flood, C. M., & Gross, A. (2014). The right to health at the public/private divide: A global comparative study. Cambridge University Press.
Forman, L., Ooms, G., Chapman, A. R., Friedman, E., Waris, A., Lamprea, E., & Mulumba, M. (2016). What could a strengthened right to health bring to the post-2015 health development agenda? Interrogating the role of the minimum core concept in advancing essential health needs. BMC International Health and Human Rights, 16, Article 23. https://doi.org/10.1186/s12914-016-0097-5
Gauri, V., & Brinks, D. M. (Eds.). (2020). Courting social justice: Judicial enforcement of social and economic rights in the developing world. Cambridge University Press.
Government of Indonesia. (2011). Law of the Republic of Indonesia Number 24 of 2011 concerning the Social Security Administering Body.
Government of Indonesia. (2023). Law of the Republic of Indonesia Number 17 of 2023 concerning Health.
Harsono, D., Ramma, L., Berman, P., Rockers, P. C., & Friedman, J. (2020). Health financing reform in Indonesia: A decade of progress towards universal health coverage. Health Systems & Reform, 6(1), Article e1810301. https://doi.org/10.1080/23288604.2020.1810301
Hart, H. L. A. (2012). The concept of law (3rd ed.). Oxford University Press. (Original work published 1961)
Heywood, P. M., & Harahap, N. P. (2019). Addressing disparities in health: Lessons from the Indonesian experience. The Lancet Global Health, 7(7), e846–e847. https://doi.org/10.1016/S2214-109X(19)30186-5
Jung, C., Rosevear, E., & Hirschl, R. (2014). Economic and social rights in national constitutions and the demand for social insurance. Northwestern University Law Review, 109(2), 367–408.
Mahendradhata, Y., Trisnantoro, L., Listyadewi, S., Soewondo, P., Marthias, T., Harimurti, P., & Prawira, J. (2017). The Republic of Indonesia health system review. World Health Organization Regional Office for South-East Asia.
Mæstad, O., & Mwisongo, A. (2011). Informal payments and the quality of health care: Mechanisms revealed by Tanzanian health workers. Health Policy, 99(2), 107–115. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.healthpol.2010.07.011
Mboi, N., Murty Surbakti, I., Trihandini, I., Elyazar, I., Houston Smith, K., Bahjuri Ali, P., Kosen, S., Flemons, K., Ray, S. E., Cao, J., Glenn, S. D., Miller-Petrie, M. K., Mooney, M. D., Ried, J. L., Nur Anggraini Ningrum, D., Idris, F., Siregar, K. N., Huda, T. M., Kereselidze, M., ... Hay, S. I. (2018). On the road to universal health care in Indonesia, 1990–2016: A systematic analysis for the Global Burden of Disease Study 2016. The Lancet, 392(10147), 581–591. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0140-6736(18)30595-6
Pieterse, M. (2014). Can rights cure? The impact of human rights litigation on South Africa's health system. Pretoria University Law Press, 17(4), 1–31.
Pisani, E., Kok, M. O., & Nugroho, K. (2017). Indonesia's road to universal health coverage: A political journey. Health Policy and Planning, 32(2), 267–276. https://doi.org/10.1093/heapol/czw120
Sparrow, R., Suryahadi, A., & Widyanti, W. (2017). Social health insurance for the poor: Targeting and impact of Indonesia's Askeskin programme. Social Science & Medicine, 96, 264–271.
Trisnantoro, L., Hendrartini, J., Susilowati, T., Miranti, P. A. D., Aristianti, V., Dewi, S. K., Listyani, R. B., Perwitasari, D., & Hidayah, N. (2019). Penguatan sistem kesehatan untuk mencapai cakupan kesehatan universal di Indonesia. Jurnal Manajemen Pelayanan Kesehatan, 22(4), 179–188.
Van der Berg, S., & Burger, R. (2010). Teacher pay in South Africa. University of Stellenbosch, Department of Economics.
Yamin, A. E., & Norheim, O. F. (2014). Taking equality seriously: Applying human rights frameworks to priority setting in health. Human Rights Quarterly, 36(2), 296–324. https://doi.org/10.1353/hrq.2014.0022
Yamin, A. E., & Parra-Vera, O. (2019). Transparency and accountability in health: Taking stock and looking ahead. Health and Human Rights, 21(2), 1–5.
Young, K. G. (2012). Constituting economic and social rights. Oxford University Press.
Young, K. G. (2017). Economic, social and cultural rights. In S. Halliday & P. Schmidt (Eds.), Human rights brought home: Socio-legal perspectives on human rights in the national context (pp. 189–210). Hart Publishing.
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2026 Raymond R. Tjandrawinata, Ina Heliany
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.
