Eduvest � Journal
of Universal Studies Volume 2 Number 11, November, 2022 p- ISSN
2775-3735 - e-ISSN 2775-3727 |
||
|
|
|
ISLAMIC
LAW CRITICISM OF MENTAL DISABILITIES MARRIAGE |
|
|
Fadllurrohman STAI At- Taqwa Bekasi,
Indonesia |
|
|
ABSTRACT |
|
|
Marriage is
the most useful and most important way in effort realize and maintain honor,
because with this marriage somebody can awake from what Allah has forbidden.
People with disabilities disability as normal human beings who are also
blessed desire sexual naturally have desire for tie self in bond marriage .
As for goals from study dissertation this is for knowing in a manner in
application: Marriage Law For disabled Mental disabilities according to Law
No. 8 of 2016, fulfillment obligation wife or husband disabled internal
mental disability marriage, implementation marriage disabled mental
disability according to the Marriage Law in Indonesia, Review of Islamic Law
concerning marriage disabled mental disability. Method research used in
writing dissertation this is study library (library research). technique deep
data collection study this conducted through studies documentation about
marriage disabled originating mental disability from books, articles,
magazines, letters news, or source literature other, which later taken
conclusion based on these data. kindly general religion of Islam is not once forbid the marriage that took place between disabled
mentally handicapped p this remember the goal base marriage that is as means
distribute desire sexual with good and true as well as as
institution preventive happening wickedness and adultery. However, clan
disability in Thing marriage not yet fully protected because they are very
risky or susceptible to divorce. |
|
|
KEYWORDS |
law
criticism; mental disabilities marriage |
|
|
This
work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution- ShareAlike
4.0 International |
|
INTRODUCTION
According to the number
of scholars, marriage is a recommendation (sunnah) for Muslims. In
Law no. 1 of 1974 it is stated that: "Marriage is an inner and outer bond
between a woman and a man as husband and wife with the aim of forming a happy
and eternal family (household) based on the belief in God Almighty." While
in the Compilation of Islamic Law "Marriage m�ts�qan ghal�dzan according
to Islamic law is a marriage, namely a strong contract or m�ts�qan ghal�dzan
to obey Allah's commands and carry it out is worship."
Marriage is one of
the general sunnatullah that applies to all creatures of Allah, both
animals and plants. Everything created by Allah is paired and matched, as is
the case with the most perfect creatures, namely humans.
Marriage as a
legal act between husband and wife, not only means to realize worship to Him, but
also creates civil law consequences between the two. However, because the goal
of marriage is to build a happy, eternal, everlasting family based on the
belief in the One and Only God, it is necessary to regulate the rights and
obligations of each husband and wife. (Rofiq, 2017) .
Humans are not
like animals who marry freely and according to their desires. For animals,
marriage is merely a need for lust and lust, while for humans, marriage is
governed by various ethics and other regulations that uphold civilized and
moral human values. Therefore, human marriage must follow the rules that apply.
Thus the relationship between a man and a woman is regulated in an honorable
manner and based on mutual approval with the consent qabul ceremony attended by
the bride and groom.
Humans are
creatures created by Allah SWT who have the same position on earth. Every human
being has dignity and worth attached to his humanity. As the Al-Quran
explains that humans are created in the best form, this indicates that humans
by nature are the best and most perfect creatures of Allah SWT compared to
other creatures of Allah SWT . (Aziz, 2021) . In the Al-Quran
letter Al Isr� verse 70 it is stated:
وَلَقَدْ
كَرَّمْنَا
بَنِي آدَمَ
وَحَمَلْنَاهُمْ
فِي الْبَرِّ
وَالْبَحْرِ
وَرَزَقْنَاهُمْ
مِنَ
الطَّيِّبَاتِ
وَفَضَّلْنَاهُمْ
عَلَىٰ
كَثِيرٍ
مِمَّنْ
خَلَقْنَا
تَفْضِيلًا
"And
indeed We have glorified the children of Adam, We carried them on land and in
the sea, We gave them sustenance from the good and We made them superior with
perfect advantages over most of the creatures We have created."
This is in line
with the number of scholars of Usul Fiqh who
say that the basis for the existence of takl�f
(legal imposition) on a mukallaf is
reason (العقل) and understanding (الفهم). Amukallaf can be burdened by law if he is wise and can
understand the takl�f properly addressed to him (Syafe, 2007) .
Therefore, people who do not or do not have intelligence are not subject to takl�f
because they are considered unable to understand the takl�f
of al-Sy�ri'.
In the rule of taklifi
law it is stated that the mahkŭm 'alaih (a person who is
burdened by law) has two conditions for imposition of law, namely: 1) being
able to understand the imposition books, namely the Qur'an and
as-Sunnah, either by himself or through an intermediary; and 2) have the
ability to accept the burden (ahliyah). In this expert concept, two
terms are known, namely first, expertyah wujŭb, namely the ability
to accept rights and obligations, where there is decency for all humans on a
humanitarian basis; and secondly, expert yatul ada' (ability to act), namely
the decency of a person to be seen as legitimate in all his words and deeds (Yahya & Rahman, 1979) .
By looking at the
expert factors above, especially expert al-ada', then people with mental
retardation certainly cannot accept the imposition of taklifi law. This
is because he does not have the appropriateness to be called a mahkŭm
'alaih (a person who is subject to legal imposition). People with mental
disabilities are classified into an imperfect condition of al-ada' experts .
Because basically his mind is not lost, but his mind is weak and lacking, then
he is punished like a mumayyiz child (Khalaf,
2003) . A safih
(idiot; belongs to a type of mental disability) is distinguished from a
child by his maturity, and from a madman by his intelligence (Mughniyah, 2004) .
The Prophet
Muhammad SAW said:
رُفِعَ
الْقَلَمُ
عَنْ
ثَلَاثَةٍ:
عَنِ النَّائِمِ
حَتَّى
يَسْتَيْقِظَ
، وعَنِ الْمُبْlection
�The
legal burden was lifted from three (people); people sleep until they wake up,
children until they reach puberty, and crazy people until they recover." (Dawud, 1984)
Marriage is a
human instinct to build a household in order to achieve peace, tranquility of
life and a sense of affection, as the word of Allah SWT, QS.Ar-Rŭm (30): 21.
وَمِنْ
آيَاتِهِ
أَنْ خَلَقَ
لَكُمْ مِنْ أَنْفُسِكُمْ
أَزْوَاجًا
لِتَسْكُنُوا
إِلَيْهَا
وَجَعَلَ
بَيْنَكُمْ
مَوَدَّةً وَرَحْمَةً
ۚ إِنَّ فِي
ذَٰلِكَ
لَآيَاتٍ لِقَوْمٍ
يَتَفَكَّرُونَ
"And
among the signs of His power is that He created for you wives of your own kind,
so that you are inclined to and feel at ease with him, and He made them love
and care for you."
The verse explains
that the purpose of marriage is very noble, namely to create a peaceful, safe
and secure family. To realize this noble goal, it must be supported by maturity
and maturity, so as to create a sense of responsibility in them.
In line with the
verse above, the Prophet Muhammad SAW gave guidance so that in carrying out a marriage
a Muslim must have preparations both physically, psychologically and
economically, as in the hadith of the Prophet, which means:
يَا
مَعْشَرَ
الشَّبَابِ
مَنِ
اسْتَطَاعَ مِنْكُمُ
الْبَاءَةَ
فَلْيَتَزَوَّجْ
فَإِنَّهُ
أَغَضُّ
لِلْبَصَرِ
وَأَحْصَنُ لِلْفَرْجِ
وَمَنْ لَمْ
يَسْتَطِعْ
فَعَلَيْهِ
بِالصَّوْمِ
فَإِنَّهُ
لَهُ وِجَاءٌ
"Hey
young man! If one of you has the ability to marry, then marry. Verily, that
lowers the gaze and guards the farji. And whoever is not able (to get married)
should fast, in fact that is a guard for him." (al-Ja'fi, 1991)
The capabilities
desired from the hadith above are physical and non-physical abilities so that
they can provide both physical and spiritual support for their wife. In living
a household life, hard work and mutual understanding are absolutely necessary
so that a harmonious life between husband and wife will be realized. To realize
the purpose of the marriage, careful preparation is needed both morally and
materially.
Article 1 of Law
No. 1 of 1974 concerning Marriage (hereinafter referred to as UUP) contains the
definition of marriage which reads: marriage is a physical and spiritual bond between
a man and a woman as husband and wife with the aim of forming a family
(household) that happy and eternal based on Belief in the One and Only God. To
be able to realize the function and purpose of the marriage, the physical and
mental maturity of the prospective bride and groom are important factors.
Without physical and mental maturity, the rights and obligations of husband and
wife in marriage will be difficult to fulfill.
In line with this,
the UUP adheres to the principle that the prospective husband is required to
have maturity/maturity in body and soul to be able to enter into a marriage.
The goal is to be able to realize the goals of marriage properly without ending
in divorce.
In reality, the
demands of ideality and reality often do not go hand in hand. Persons with
mental disabilities as normal human beings who are also endowed with sexual
desire certainly have the desire to bind themselves in the bonds of marriage.
This becomes something natural. However, with their level of intelligence that
is less or below normal it is feared that people with disabilities cannot
control their emotions or cannot be mature in dealing with a problem. In
addition, they are also worried that they will not be able to meet the family's
living needs. This in turn can cause problems in the family and a burden on the
parents.
Islam does not
state mental maturity as one of the conditions or pillars of marriage. Islam
only argues that the institution of marriage is a sacred institution that has
wisdom to save human life in this world and the hereafter. Nevertheless, the
institution of marriage in fostering future generations from each family
contains a recommendation that anyone who enters household life should have
maturity, both physically and mentally. (Muchtar, 2016) . The UUP
and KHI also do not mention ' aqil (reasonable) as a condition for a
valid marriage. However, implicitly the existence of a minimum age limit for
the two bride and groom is an answer to the importance of being akil as a
requirement for the bride and groom.
In marriages of
people with mental disabilities, marriage is not solely for the fulfillment of
biological needs, but the main thing is the fulfillment of human affectional
needs, namely the need to love and be loved, to feel affection, to feel safe
and protected, to be appreciated, to be cared for and so on. Likewise, material
needs are not the main basis for achieving happiness.
In terms of mental
health, a husband/wife who is bound in a marriage will not get happiness, when
the marriage is only based on meeting biological and material needs alone
without meeting affective needs (love). Affective factors which are the main
pillars for the stability of a marriage/household (Hawari, 1997) .
Marriage as a
contract that justifies intimate relations between a man and a woman, shows the
most basic function of marriage, namely as a preventive institution for the
occurrence of things that are prohibited by religion, namely adultery and
wickedness. It is through this marriage that it is hoped that human nature can
be properly maintained, because marriage regulates sexual relations between
women and men with legal ties.
Disability is a
humanitarian issue in Indonesia. The negative stigma against persons with
disabilities that is still attached to Indonesian society is a problem in
itself. Among the various types of disabilities, people with mental
disabilities are considered as a group that is less accepted in society. This
is due to the inherent assumption that they are unable to control their
desires, emotions, and lack the ability to socialize with other people
(Selway
& Ashman, 1998) . Shelway and Ashman note that the majority in the community,
people with HIV/AIDS, mental disabilities, mental illness, and cerebal palsy
are groups that are rarely accepted in society.
The data shows that the
number of persons with disabilities in Indonesia is currently at 12 percent
according to a survey conducted by the Central Statistics Agency (BPS). The
large number of persons with disabilities certainly requires special treatment
and policies from the government to fulfill their rights as citizens and
protect them from all forms of discrimination.
Even
though the number of people with disabilities is so large, the Indonesian
public's attention to them is still relatively low. Not a few people with
disabilities experience discriminatory treatment, starting from the family
environment to the community. Their physical and mental limitations are often
seen as a "curse" . Even if some people start to raise
awareness about the importance of paying attention to persons with
disabilities, then it is nothing more than a discourse. Everywhere persons with
disabilities are still considered a troublesome subject.
Regardless
of the conditions experienced, basically every human being has the same right
to obtain happiness in his life. Everyone has the right to grow and develop in
a conducive and supportive environment, including those with mental
retardation. In the Declaration on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities
issued by the UN General Assembly, it is stated that playing an active role in
a family is one of their rights. In Indonesia their rights are protected in Law
no. 8 of 2016 concerning persons with disabilities.
Humans
in carrying out social life in society cannot be separated from the existence
of interdependence between humans and others. This is because in accordance
with the position of humans as social beings who like to be in groups or make
friends with other humans. Living together is one of the means to meet the
needs of human life, both physical and spiritual needs. Likewise for a man or a
woman who has reached a certain age then he will not be separated from these
problems. He wants to fulfill his life's needs and go through it together with
other people who can be used as an outpouring of soothing souls, a place to
share joys and sorrows. Living together between a man and a woman as husband
and wife and fulfilling the legal provisions is what is commonly referred to as
a marriage.
Marriage
is the most useful and most important way in an effort to realize and maintain
honor, because with this marriage a person can be protected from what Allah SWT
has forbidden. That is why Rasulullah SAW encouraged to speed up marriage, make
the road easier for him and eradicate his obstacles.
Article
1 of Law No. 1 of 1974 concerning Marriage (hereinafter referred to as UUP)
contains the definition of marriage which reads: marriage is a physical and
spiritual bond between a man and a woman as husband and wife with the aim of
forming a family (household) that happy and eternal based on Belief in the One
and Only God (Bardizbah, nd) .
Likewise in Law No. 8 of 2016 concerning persons with disabilities in article 8
part four it states that: the rights of privacy for persons with disabilities
include having the right to form a family and continue offspring through legal
marriage.�����������
To
be able to realize the function and purpose of the marriage, the physical and
mental maturity of the prospective bride and groom are an important factor.
Without physical and mental maturity, the rights and obligations of husband and
wife in marriage will be difficult to fulfill.
In
line with this, the UUP adheres to the principle that the prospective husband
must be mentally and physically mature to be able to enter into a marriage. The
goal is to be able to realize the goals of marriage properly without ending in
divorce.
In
reality, the demands of ideality and reality often do not go hand in hand.
Persons with disabilities as normal human beings who are also endowed with
sexual desires certainly have the desire to bind themselves in marriage ties.
This is something that is very reasonable. However, with their shortcomings it
is feared that they will find it difficult to carry out the ark life of their
household life. In addition, they are also worried that they will not be able
to meet the family's living needs later. This in turn can cause problems in the
family and can cause a burden on the parents.
From
his
description above, there are at least a number of problems that must be
explored related to marriage with mental disabilities, namely:
a.
There is a desire in persons with mental
disabilities to get married which is driven by mature sexual development
b.
There are problems that may arise in
marriages with mental disabilities
c.
A more in-depth study needs to be carried
out regarding the benefits and harms for the bride and the
surrounding community, also by looking at it from the perspective of Islamic
law.
d.
Seeing that people with mental
disabilities themselves cannot take care of their interests and needs, and with
the reasons above, of course, it is necessary to re-examine how the phenomenon
of marriage for people who suffer from mental retardation.
e.
Finally, is the implementation of Law No.
8 of 2016 concerning Persons with Disabilities related to marriages of persons
with mental disabilities.
Therefore,
it is necessary to have a more in-depth study of marriages with mental
disabilities in the perspective of Islamic law and laws regarding persons with
disabilities in regulating their rights to carry out conditional marriages and
after the marriage takes place, so the author is very interested in analyzing
this problem and raised it in his dissertation. entitled " Criticism of Islamic Law on the
Implementation of Law No. 8 of 2016 concerning Marriage with Mental
Disabilities �.
RESEARCH
METHOD
This research is a
form of field research using a
qualitative descriptive research approach. Qualitative research is research
based on descriptive exposure to existing phenomena in an argumentative form.
This study aims to obtain a complete picture of the research subject according
to the views of the people studied (Basuki, 2006) .
According to
Somantri, the qualitative research method is a method that is systematically
used by researchers in collecting the data needed in the process of identifying
and explaining the social phenomena they are studying. (Somantri, 2005) .
Based on this
review, the researchers in this study explained the phenomena and findings of
researchers in the field descriptively based on these findings and data .
RESULTS AND
DISCUSSION
A. Observation Results of Marriage Practices
for Persons with Mental Disabilities
The first observation was
carried out at the Jamrud Biru Foundation for Mental Disability Rehabilitation,
Bekasi City , located on Jl. Asemsari Jl . Asem Sari II, RT.003/RW.004, Mustikasari, Kec. Mustika
Jaya, Bekasi City, West Java. The phenomenon that occurs at
the Jamrud Biru Foundation for Mental Disability Rehabilitation in
Bekasi City is that there are
several marriage practices carried out by people with mental disabilities. In
order to equalize perceptions, what is meant by mentally disabled people at the
Jamrud Biru Foundation for Mental Disability Rehabilitation, Bekasi City in this study are people who are in the
orphanage who are not focused on
people with mental disorders (OGDJ) who only receive mental rehabilitation, but
also including graduates, staff and people who are at the Jamrud Biru
Foundation for Mental Disabilities Rehabilitation, Bekasi City . So that the perpetrators of marriage
here are also included in it.
In general, the
practice of marriages carried out by people with mental disabilities has been
carried out by many graduates. However, with limited information, only 3 pairs
of husband and wife expressed their willingness to be interviewed. This is
because some of the other respondents are no longer in the foundation so it is
difficult to find them. Some of these pairs are as follows:
1. Mr. HSN and Mrs. Is
Mr. Previously, Hsn was a
person with a mental disability who attended rehabilitation at the Jamrud Biru
Foundation, Bekasi City. After his condition stabilized, he was seconded as a
cleaning staff at the Jamrud Biru Foundation, Bekasi City Mental Rehabilitation
Center as a Cleaning Staff and Mis. Is as a Cook. They married in May 2006,
have no children, and live in the Jamrud Biru Foundation's Mental Disability
Rehabilitation Center.
According to Mr. Hsn and Ms. Is as follows:
We are married to love and care for each other, we
agree to be faithful and share each other's joys and sorrows. Maybe other
people think we are unhappy, even though we are happy like other people in
general .
2. Mr. Fjr and Mrs. Ant
Mr. Fjr and Miss. Ant works
at the Jamrud Biru Foundation for Mental Disability Rehabilitation, Bekasi
City, are people with mental disabilities who have attended the stages of
rehabilitation and are considered to be able to control their psyche well, so
they are seconded as Cleaning Staff. They carried out their marriage in August
2003, and were blessed with 1 child who was raised by the mother and sister of
Mrs. Miss. AN. They both live in the Employee Mess of the Mental Disability
Rehabilitation Center at the Jamrud Biru Foundation, Bekasi City.
Description Mr. Fjd and Ms. Ants as follows:
Well, those whose names are
husband and wife, of course there will be opposition, well one has to give in.
If both of you want to win, there can't be a meeting point. We got married like
people in general, so we used a qabul consent, there were witnesses, there were
guardians who also used a dowry
3. Mr. Dnl and Mrs. Adh
Mr. Dnl, who was previously
a person with disabilities and was able to socialize like normal humans, was
seconded to work at the Jamrud Biru Foundation Mental Disability Rehabilitation
Institution, Bekasi City as Security Staff (Night Watch) and Miss. Adh is a
Cleaning Staff (Launcher) and not a person with mental disorders (ODGJ). One of
Mr.'s motivations. Dnl can gradually improve due to encouragement from Miss.
Adh. This is what they both married in February 1994, blessed with 2 children.
In 1996, they bought a modest house in the vicinity of the Jamrud Biru
Foundation's Mental Disability Rehabilitation Center.
4. Mr. Dll and Miss. Ant explained to researchers:
Marriage starts from zero,
so you don't have anything, roughly speaking, only clothes are attached. But we
save little by little and save money. Finally, we have our own house and
savings, even though it's not much, we are grateful to be able to enjoy life and
experience the ups and downs in the life of a household. Marriage is carried
out in accordance with religious regulations as well as state law.
Marriage practices carried
out by people with mental disabilities here are the same as normal human
beings. There is a process of introduction (dating), propose, and marriage. In
the process of marriage they also make a contract, and
this contract is witnessed by both parents, and includes a guardian and a
registrar
They went through the
marriage process after graduating from this Foundation. In the sense that their
life maturity process is already a guarantee, although on the one hand they are
still below normal adult humans in general. They also have an instinctive love
and being loved. The foundation of their marriage is affection, love and
belonging to each other.
Even though there are some
who are not or have not been blessed with children, with the evidence of
children, it can be concluded here that their sexual relations also proceed as
normal people .
The term "mental
disability" in several references is also referred to as children with
subnormal mental disorders, mental retardation, weak memory, febleminded,
mentally retarded. All the meanings of these terms are the same, which refers
to someone who has below normal mental intelligence. Limitations regarding
children with mental disabilities or mental retardation, experts define
differently in several references. The difference in ownership is closely
related to its goals and interests. From these various insights, various
definitions of mental retardation emerge, but substantially they do not reduce
the meaning of the notion of mental retardation itself, even though in their
insights they use a different approach. A person is categorized as mentally disabled
or mentally retarded, if he has such a low level of intelligence (below
normal), that to carry out his developmental tasks he requires specific
assistance or services, including in his education program. (Effendi, 2005) .
The wrong interpretation
often occurs in ordinary society that a state of mental disability or
intellectual disability is considered as a disease so that by entering into an
educational institution or special care, it is hoped that the child will return
to normal. This interpretation is completely incorrect because mentally
retarded children at any level have absolutely nothing to do with disease or
the same as disease. Because of that, it is natural that children with mental
disabilities also have the same needs as people in general, including the need
to have children, get love, love each other and even get married.
Based on this, the
phenomenon that occurs at the Jamrud Biru Foundation's Mental Disability
Rehabilitation Center in Bekasi City is that there are several marriage
practices carried out by people with mental disabilities. It is not surprising
then that there is a phenomenon of marriages between men and women with mental
disabilities being able to take the same path as people in general. One thing
that was surprising, it turns out that in practice their household life, they
can get normal offspring, and mentally disabled husband and wife can live in
harmony and even be happy. This is evidenced by the narrative of several
respondents who in essence they stated as follows:
We got married like normal
people, yes we used a qabul consent, there were witnesses, there were guardians
who also used a dowry. We got married according to religious rules as well as
laws. Administrative requirements are also met. We are also ordinary people
need each other. Yes, I want to have children and it turns out that I already
have children. Yes, the marriage is done in a simple way, but we obey the rules
Marriage starts from zero, so you don't have anything,
roughly speaking, only clothes are attached. But we save little by little and
save money. Finally, we have our own house and savings, even though it's not
much, we are grateful to be able to enjoy life and experience the ups and downs
in the life of a household. Marriage is carried out in accordance with
religious regulations as well as state law.
The statements of married
couples who are mentally disabled as above, show that from the aspect of
biological needs, it turns out that they are capable, that is, the husband is
able to provide physical as well as spiritual support, as well as the wife is
able to carry out her obligations to serve her husband well. Judging from the
aspect of marriage, it turns out that they can live harmoniously and happily
and can enjoy the meaning and meaning of life. Judging from their work, it
turns out that they are also capable of creating and achieving. Even though
what is noteworthy is that they feel they are not getting enough attention from
the government (especially the social and health services) and adequate
education like other normal humans, besides that their ability is below the
average normal human being in capturing information coupled with the lack of
instructor.
�The second observation, made of the couple with the initials Mr. Sm and
Mrs. Is, who is married, is both from Yogyakarta and settled to make a living
in Bekasi. At first, the two were actually a non-disabled couple. But after a
few years of marriage, Mrs. Ist has a disability caused by an accident. Because
of this limitation, the husband divorced his wife.
�I left my wife after my wife fell from a motorcycle
accident and hit her head. After the accident, the atmosphere at home became
different, especially my wife, whose memory is impaired, and her ability to
communicate isn't what it used to be. If you want to have sex, your wife often
refuses, even though in the past she was always ready whenever I wanted, in the
end, my wife and I used to make a fuss or fight because my wife was no longer
able to serve me, especially in matters of bed. In the end I divorced rather
than making a fuss.
This description is one of
the bitter realities in household life, especially for people with disabilities
who have not been fully protected. As stated in the Law. No. 1 of 1974
concerning marriage, article 39 paragraph 2 letter e, and the Compilation of
Islamic Law article 116 letter (e), actually approves of divorce on the grounds
that one of the parties is disabled or due to illness, which causes them to no
longer be able to carry out their obligations as husband/wife.
B.
Review of
Islamic Law on Marriage for Persons with Mental Disabilities
Marriage is an innate need of every human being that
provides many important results (Effendi, 2005) . Marriage
is very important in human life, both individually and in groups. Through legal
marriage, the association of men and women occurs in an honorable manner
according to the position of humans as creatures of honor. Association of
household life is fostered in an atmosphere of peace, tranquility, and a sense
of affection between husband and wife. Children from legitimate marriages adorn
family life and are at the same time the continuity of human life in a clean and
honorable manner (Azhar, 2004) .
In Article 1 Chapter I of the Marriage Law Number 1 of
1974 dated January 2, 1974 it is stated; "Marriage is an inner and outer
bond between a man and a woman as husband and wife with the aim of forming a
happy and eternal family (household) based on Belief in the One Almighty God."
(Suma, 2004) In Article
2 KHI, marriage according to Islamic law is a marriage, namely a very strong
contract or miitsaaqan ghalizhan to obey Allah's commands and carrying them out
is worship. (Saekan & Effendi, 1997) .
As-Shan'ani in his book explains that an-nik�h according
to the meaning of language is a merger and mutual inclusion and mixing. The
word "marriage" is in the sense of "intercourse" and
"contract". There are people who say "marriage" is a majaz
word from the general expression for the name of the cause of the cause. There
are also those who say that "marriage" is the essence of meaning for
both of them, and that is what is meant by those who say that the word
"marriage" is mutually exclusive for both of them. The word
marriage is often used in the contract. There are also those who say that the
word marriage contains an intrinsic meaning that is syar'i. The word marriage
is not meant in the Qur'an except in terms of contract (Al-San'ani, 1999) .
From the various meanings above, although the
editorial is different, there are similarities. Therefore, it can be concluded
that marriage is a contract or agreement to justify sexual relations between
men and women in order to realize the happiness of family life filled with a
sense of peace and love in a way that pleases Allah SWT. In this context the
Prophet said:
Meaning: Has informed us from Abu Bakr bin Nafi
'al-'Abdiy from Bahz from Hammad bin Salamah from Thabit from Anas; In fact,
some of the companions of the Prophet SAW asked the wives of the Prophet SAW
about what he was doing secretly. Some of them said that he did not marry
women. Some say that he never ate meat. And some say that he never sleeps with
a mat on. Hearing this, the Prophet SAW praised Allah. And then he said:
"What do those people want with what they said earlier? Actually, I also
sleep while praying, while fasting, I also break my fast. And I also marry a
woman. Whoever doesn't like my Sunnah, then he is not one of my group."
(HR. Muslim) (bin Hajjaj Alqusyairi, nd) .
Marriage is not just a means of justifying sexual
relations, but is also oriented towards forming a family and fulfilling the
inherent obligations as a consequence of the contract. One of the consequences
of this obligation is the obligation to nurture, educate, both mentally and
spiritually, and raise children. Article 77 paragraph 3 of the Compilation of
Islamic Law states:
Husband
and wife bear the obligation to care for and care for their children, both
regarding physical, spiritual and intellectual growth and religious education (Abdullah, 1994) .
In the rules of
taklifi law it is stated that mahkŭm fih means "the actions of
a mulatto person as a place to link syara' law". For example, in
verse 1 of Surat al-Maidah Allah says:
يَا
أَيُّهَا
الَّذِينَ
آمَنُوا
أَوْفُوا
بِالْعُقُودِ
ۚ أُحِلَّتْ
لَكُمْ بَهِيمَةُ
الْأَنْعَامِ
إِلَّا مَا
يُتْلَىٰ عَلَيْكُمْ
غَيْرَ
مُحِلِّي
الصَّيْدِ
وَأَنْتُمْ
حُرُمٌ ۗ
إِنَّ
اللَّهَ
يَحْكُمُ مَا
يُرِيدُ
"O you who believe, fulfill
the contracts. Cattle are lawful for you, except for those that will be recited
to you. (That is so) by not making hunting lawful while you are performing
Hajj. Verily, Allah sets laws according to what He wills.
The object of the
commandment in the verse is the act of the mukallaf person, namely the act of
fulfilling the promise required by the verse. The terms of Mahkŭm f�h ,
that there are several requirements for the validity of a legal action:
a.
The act is known perfectly and in detail
by the mulatto so that an order, for example, can be carried out completely as
desired by Allah or His Messenger. Therefore, as stated by Abd al-Wahhab
Khallaf, the verses of the Qur'an which were revealed globally, must only be
implemented after an explanation from His Messenger. For example, the verses of
the Al-Qur'an which oblige prayers globally without specifying the conditions
and pillars of it, are only obligatory to be implemented after a detailed
explanation has been given from the Prophet. Likewise the verses that command
to carry out pilgrimage, fasting, and zakat.
b.
It is known with certainty by the mukallaf
that the order came from the party authorized to make the order, which in
this case is Allah and His Messenger. That is why in every effort to find a
legal solution, the first thing to do is to discuss the validity of an argument
as a source of law.
c.
Actions that are ordered or prohibited
must be in the form of actions that are within the limits of human ability to
do or leave it. This is because the purpose of a command or prohibition is to
be obeyed. Therefore, it is impossible that there is in the Al-Qur'an and
Sunnah a commandment that is logically impossible for humans to carry out. For
example the command to fly without using tools.
As for mahkŭm
'alaih , it means "amukallaf person ( a person who deserves to
be burdened with taklifi law )". A new person is considered worthy
of being burdened with taklifi law if he has several conditions:
1.
Able to understand legal arguments either
independently or with the help of other people, at least to the extent that it
allows him to practice the contents of the verses or hadiths of the Prophet.
The existence of the ability to understand the law of taklifi is because
a person has a perfect mind. When measured by physical growth, the limit of
puberty makes sense for women with the start of menstruation and for men the
first dream of sexual intercourse. However, if by the age of fifteen a woman
does not menstruate and a man does not dream, then the age of fifteen is
considered the minimum age of puberty.
2.
Have expertyat
al-ada', namely the ability to act legally or
carry the burden of taklif. With such skills a person is called amukallaf,
meaning that all his actions are taken into account by Islamic law, and he is
warned to carry out all orders and stay away from prohibitions. Skills like
this are only possessed by a person perfectly when he reaches the age of reason
and is free from all things that hinder this skill, such as being crazy,
sleeping, forgetting, being forced, and so on which are explained in detail in
the Usul books. Fiqh Especially with regard to property, a person's authority
is only considered valid in addition to having reached puberty and having
intelligence, namely the ability to control his wealth. A person who has
reached the age of puberty has reason, but is unable to control his wealth,
such as being redundant, is not considered capable of controlling his wealth,
and therefore he needs to be guided by a person in charge. (Zuhudi, 2019)
In this expert
concept, two terms are known, namely; first, expertyah
wujŭb, namely the ability to accept rights and obligations, where
there is decency for all human beings on a humanitarian basis; and secondly,
expert yatul ada' (ability to act), namely the decency of a person to be
seen as legitimate in all his words and deeds.
With Seeing the al-ada' expert factors
above, people with mental retardation certainly cannot accept the imposition of
taklifi law. This is because he does not have the appropriateness to be
called a mahkŭm 'alaih (a person who is subject to legal
imposition).
The Prophet
Muhammad SAW said:
Meaning: Has informed us from Affan from
Hammad from Ibrahim from al-Aswad from 'Aisyah from
the Prophet SAW said: the law cannot be imposed on three people, namely: 1).
People sleep until he wakes up 2). Small child until he grows up, and 3). Mad
man so he realized. (Narrated by Ahmad).
Mukhtar Yahya
further wrote that there are three types of actions that must be considered in
determining whether or not the actions taken by mumayyiz
are legal, namely:
a.
In transactions that contain benefits,
such as receiving grants and shadaqah, then the action is legal.
b.
In transactions that contain elements of
transfer of property rights, such as giving grants, wills, and endowments, then
the action is not valid.
c.
In an action in which there is an element
of benefit and the transfer of rights at the same time, such as buying and
selling, and leasing, then it is considered valid if there is permission from
the guardian and if the guardian does not allow it, the action becomes null and
void. (Muhtar, n.d.) .
In terms of
contract, the contract in marriage is equated with the contract in buying and
selling. Sheikh Abu Yahya Zakariya al-Anshori wrote that what is required in
the shigat of marriage is what is required in the shighat of buying and
selling.
وشرط
فيها أي في
صغة ما شرط في
صغة النكاح
"And
the conditions in the marriage contract mean what is required in the shigat
nikah, what is required in the sale and purchase agreement."
Imam Shafi'i
defines the idiotic safih quoted by Sheikh Abu Yahya in the chapter Al-Hijr as
follows:
Peace be upon you
�Imam
Syafi'i interprets the word safih as a wasteful person, a weak person (both
children and adults) who (can be) deceived, and a person who is unable to focus
because of his maghluban (lack of) mind.
Where in the law
of buying and selling it is required for '�qid (a person who has a
contract) to have the absoluteness to transfer assets. So that the contract is
invalid for people who are carried out by children, crazy people or people who
are under a ban on the use of property (al-hijr) in the presence of
sanctity.
Regarding the
legal issues of marriage carried out by people with mental disabilities, there
are several differences of opinion. In the book Al-Mizan al-Kubra, it is
stated:
The opinion of Imam Tsalatsah (Hanbali,
Maliki, Syafi'i) and Jumhur Fuqaha: actually marriage is not valid unless it is
carried out by a person who has the ability to transfer assets. And Abu
Hanifah's opinion is that in fact marriages carried out by young children who
are mumayyiz and idiots are valid but with the approval of a guardian.
In the difference
above, Abil Mawahib tends to choose Hanafi's opinion. Because assuming other
opinions are still weak. However, Imam Shafi'i explained further about the
matter in his book Al-Umm that:
Imam Syafi'i said: in the case of adults
with mental disabilities, the father is allowed to marry them off. Because
there is no business for that person over him.
�And no one other
than their guardian may marry someone with a mental disability then
it is conveyed to the judge about the condition of the groom and the judge asks
the groom (about his intention to marry). If he wants to marry, the condition
of the groom is conveyed to the bride. If the bride is pleased with the
condition of the groom, then we will lose. If it is seen that the groom is not
ready to marry, due to paralysis and so on, the judge cannot marry him, and
neither can his father. Unless the marriage is intended to serve (take care of
the husband), then the marriage is permissible.
Thus, it can be
concluded that basically marriages carried out by people with mental
disabilities are prohibited. If seen in the taklifi rules, a safih (idiot
sufferer) does not have the appropriateness to be seen by his words and deeds.
However, if there is permission from the guardian (either a nasab guardian or a
judge's guardian) the marriage can take place. Of course this is also with the
consent of the bride with the condition of her future husband.
People with mental
disabilities (mental disabilities) are a real phenomenon of mental deviations
that often occur in children. This makes them dependent on other people in
living and fulfilling their needs. However, as has been explained, it turns out
that people with disabilities are still sexual beings, who have sexual urges,
and who want to express them in the form of sexual behavior. This is certainly
very worthy of being questioned, especially in the matter of justifying sexual
intercourse as a form of expression of sexual behavior.
In Law Number 4 of 1997 it states in
article 5 that:
Every person with
disabilities has the same rights and opportunities in all aspects of life and
livelihood . So that as a member of the state, of
course, people with mental disabilities should also pay attention.
The practice of
marriages carried out by people with mental disabilities has often occurred.
However, most of them do not know how the actual marriage law is in Islam.
According to the research conducted by the author, several conclusions were
drawn about the marriage of people with mental disabilities, namely as follows:
The first
observation, research conducted on people with mental disabilities who practice
marriage at a rehabilitation center are graduates of the foundation who have
undergone the rehabilitation process. Thus at least they have fulfilled the
basic ability to live a normal life.
In its
implementation, the contract uttered by the groom in the wedding was attended
by the bride and groom, two witnesses, parents (guardians) from both parties,
and the marriage registrar.
In general, the
contract has fulfilled the pillars of marriage. And if the perpetrators of the
contract (husbands) are not equated with normal adults as in point 1, of course
they also fulfill the requirements for the approval of a guardian, as required
by the taklifi rules.
In the taklifi
rule it is said that, in actions in which
there is an element of benefit and the transfer of rights at the same time,
such as buying and selling, and leasing, then it is considered valid if there
is permission from the guardian and if it is not permitted by the guardian then
the action becomes void.
Likewise with the
opinion of the fiqh scholars who require permission and approval from the
guardian when a safih is to carry out a marriage.
Regarding the
provision of maintenance and maintenance of children, the authors conclude that
there is no significant difference in the two issues.
This is based on
the fact that the interviewee with mental disabilities in this first
observation has a permanent job which is considered sufficient to provide a
living. So is the case with giving spiritual sustenance. This is reflected in
the existence of several perpetrators of the marriage who have had children. So
that there is no violation of article 77 paragraph 3 of the Compilation of
Islamic Law:
Husband and wife
bear the obligation to care for and care for their children, both regarding
their physical, spiritual and intellectual growth and religious education.
Marriage with
Mental Disabilities According to Islamic Law Each pillar of the contract has
certain conditions. Without fulfilling the conditions, it means that the
pillars do not meet the conditions as they should, so that the contract becomes
invalid. The most important element for the realization of a contract is ( 'aqid�ni
or the two parties who hold the contract). That is according to the view of
the majority of fuqah�' . However, not everyone is capable of
contracting. Some are completely incapable of performing any contract, some are
capable of performing some contracts, and some are capable of performing all
contracts. Ability means ability, skill, or authority that exists or is
recognized in a person. The ability associated with law in this case is a
translation of the term expertyah in Arabic.
There are two
kinds of abilities, namely:
Ability to accept (ahliyat
al-wujub) (Shah, 1992)
Experts al wujub,
as the basis for recognition of the right to receive is humanity, whether he is
an adult or still a child who is intelligent (mumayyiz) or not, male or
female, free or slave even though ( Ahliyat
al-wujub or entitled to receive) free people more perfect than slaves.
Ahyat al-wujub :
1)
Akhiryat al-wujub al-naqishah, namely the
ability to accept is not full.
The intention is not full of ability (ahliyah) only
in terms of receiving it, not in terms of doing it. A fetus that is still in
its mother's womb does not yet have its own existence, but it can receive its
rights that do not require acceptance such as inheritance, wills, endowments
which are its rights. Fetus and baby rights are recognized, and the second
right is obliged to fulfill them. The recognition of his right to receive, but
he is not obliged to do for others, is called the ability to receive not full.
2)
Akhiryat al-wujub al-kamilah, namely the
ability to fully accept. That is the right that a person has from birth into
the world until death, then he has the right to inherit and inherit; and is
obliged to earn a living as his property must be maintained by his guardian.
This right of full ability to receive cannot be lost due to madness, even
though the madness continues, it is called perfect receptive ability.
2. Ability to perform work (ahliyat al-ada')
Ahalyat al-ada', namely the
propriety of a person to do what is considered valid by syara' .
Expertise al-ada' there are
two kinds:
a.
ability to act (ahliyat al-ada'
al-naqishah), namely the propriety of acting for a person only in part, is
not fully authorized to act. If he does something, he must be under the
guidance of someone who has a perfect mind who can know the benefits or not of
the benefits of something he does, profit or loss. Like a child who is buying
and selling, this work cannot be done but under the supervision of a person
whose mind is perfect. The child's actions are training and education to face
his future. The actions of the children under supervision are only muamalah
maliyah acts. The end of the childhood is when they are baligh again
intelligent.
b.
The ability to do full (ahliyat al-ada'
al-kamilah), namely the propriety of a person to do an act that is
considered valid by syara', whether done orally or by action, whether it is
related to God's rights or human rights.
The basis for determining the ability to do full is
reason. If the development of a person's mind has begun to be perfect, then
that person is included in the category of full-fledged ability. If his mind is
not perfect, then he is included in the category of incomplete acting ability.
Scholars agree that what is the basis of the ability
to act is reason. If a person's mind is still lacking, then he cannot be
burdened with obligations. Conversely, if his mind is perfect then he is
obliged to fulfill what is his obligation. Based on this, some of the skills to
act are perfect (ahliyah ada' we are) and some are imperfect (ahliyah
ada' naqisah). Someone who already has perfect abilities (our experts) can
experience obstacles that reduce or eliminate his abilities. The loss of this
ability is called a barrier to ability ('awaridhyahyah), which is a
condition where an adult and intelligent person gets an obstacle due to a
decrease in reason or loss of reason.
Capability barriers can be divided into:
1.
Natural obstacles ('awaridh samawiyah),
obstacles that occur beyond human ability, or abilities that result in the
ability to carry out the law completely will disappear completely, such as
going crazy, sleeping, fainting, forgetting, convulsions, and stupidity. These
people are considered to have no expertise in implementing it at all and it is
not legal to manage it, nor does it have any traces of syara' .
2.
Obstacles that are not natural ('awaridh
ghairu samawiyah), obstacles that occur due to human actions. There are two
kinds of obstacles:
a)
from oneself, i.e. stupid, drunken, and
heedless,
b)
from others, namely forced.
Meanwhile, in marriage, the limit of puberty is not
only wet dreams or menstruation, but the prospective bride and groom must also
be mature and ready both physically and psychologically. However, due to the
decline in morals in modern times which has led to many violations of
sexuality, the provisions for coming of age and adulthood for prospective
brides and grooms must be based on the benefit of the law. In this case, the
qadi also plays a role in determining whether someone who wants to marry is
suitable or not for marriage. Several other clerics who also allow it are the
clerics of Gaza and Egypt, as quoted by Vardit Rispler in his book entitled Disability in Islamic Law:
�
In a fatwa from Gaza (1998) Sheikh
Muhammad Dib Qusa is asked whether retarded people may marry at all. He
concludes that they may, only if they show attraction to members of the
opposite sex. He explains that sanity (�aql) is not a prerequisite for marriage.
In an Egyptian fatwa, the mufti distinguishes between �atah (mental deficiency)
and junun (insanity), claming that �atah is a quiet insanity and junun is a
violent extrovert insanity. He permits the marriage of a ma'tuh (one who has
�atah) only as long as he or she can differentiate between good and evil, and
if they have their guardian's consent to marry. "Atah contrary to junun,
is believed to be less hazardous to the partner." (Rispler-Chaim, 2006)
With some consideration that; first, mental
disabilities or mental retardation have several levels based on their severity,
and second, that marriages with mental disabilities are also preventive
institutions for sexual exploitation or sexual acts that are clearly prohibited
by religion, the researcher concludes that it is appropriate for marriage
between them allowed
Based on their characteristics, people with mental
disabilities in the educated type (IQ 50-70) have the ability to marry. Apart
from having a strong drive for sexual rights, they can also be educated and
trained in dealing with married life. The fact that people with mental
disabilities are considered asexual beings causes a lack of sexual education
that they receive. Even though not all people with mental disabilities are the
same in their learning capacity, emotional stability, and social skills. This
is what then causes many teenagers with mental retardation to look for ways to
vent their sexual needs. The easiest and most common way is to masturbate or
masturbate.
In a study conducted by Khusnul Khotimah at an SLB in
the city of Yogyakarta, it was found that some teenagers with mental
disabilities masturbate or masturbate to get sexual satisfaction. This is
driven, among other things, by reasons such as the lack of intelligence
abilities of people with mental disabilities, sexual tension, and the
occurrence of sexual maturity due to the influence of reproductive hormones.
Masturbation or masturbation is sexual abuse in the form of stimulating one's
own genitals manually (by hand) or digitally with fingers or other means to
obtain sexual satisfaction. (Kartono, 2009) . Another
definition of masturbation or masturbation is an attempt to achieve an erection
of the sexual organs and obtain an orgasm through manual stimulation or
mechanical stimulation. This is clearly prohibited by the Shari'ah as the word
of Allah SWT, surah al-mu'minun verses 5-7:
وَالَّذِينَ
هُمْ
لِفُرُوجِهِمْ
حَافِظُون۞ وَالَّذِينَ
هُمْ
لِفُرُوجِهِمْ
حَافِظُونَ
إِلَّا
عَلَىٰ
أَزْوَاج View ۞ فَمَنِ
ابْتَغَىٰ
وَرَاءَ
ذَٰلِكَ
فَأُولَٰئِكَ
هُمُ
الْعَادُونَ ۞
�And
the people guarding his privates. Except for their wives or the slaves they
own, they are not blameless in this matter. Whoever seeks behind it, they are
the ones who transgress the limits."
Uncontrolled masturbation or masturbation will have a
bad effect on the formation of one's character. Therefore, more special
handling and attention is needed for people with mental disabilities,
especially in the field of sexual education.
The purpose of establishing Islamic law is to fulfill
the needs of human life which are primary, secondary and tertiary, so the
channeling of sexual desires by marriage should be allowed without being
complicated.
Seeing the considerations above, this is in accordance
with the ushul fiqh perspective which is reflected in the rules:
إذا
تعارض ضرران
دفع أخفهما
"Which
means that if there are two harms, then the one with the lighter one is
chosen."
The emergence of obstacles in the implementation of
the rights and obligations of husband and wife, especially in terms of
material, is lighter in meaning than when adultery arises between them.
That evil must be eliminated, which in this case is the occurrence of
wickedness and adultery which is forbidden.
A good marriage is a marriage that can bring benefits,
not to bring harm in religion. This benefit is applied to become a law that is
clean from things that violate religious rules. In this case there are five
main elements that are guarded and maintained for the benefit of humans in
carrying out marriages with mental disabilities. These five elements must be
upheld, otherwise the marriage is considered fatal in religion.
When analyzed further, marriages with mental
disabilities actually contain maintenance of the five main elements,
maintenance of religion and soul for example. In the maintenance of religion,
this marriage has prevented the perpetrator from a relationship outside of a
legal marriage which is prohibited by religion. And in caring for the soul,
this marriage makes the souls calm because the need for love and affection has
been fulfilled.
In Al-Ruum verse 21 it is stated:
وَمِنْ
آيَاتِهِ
أَنْ خَلَقَ
لَكُمْ مِنْ أَنْفُسِكُمْ
أَزْوَاجًا
لِتَسْكُنُوا
إِلَيْهَا
وَجَعَلَ
بَيْنَكُمْ
مَوَدَّةً وَرَحْمَةً
ۚ إِنَّ فِي
ذَٰلِكَ
لَآيَاتٍ لِقَوْمٍ
يَتَفَكَّرُونَ
�And
among the signs of His power is that He has created for you wives of your own
kind, so that you are inclined to and feel at ease with him, and He made them
between you with love and affection. Indeed, in that there are signs for people
who think.
The verse above explicitly underlines that the purpose
of marriage is not merely a matter of biological needs, but there are other,
more essential goals, namely love and inner peace. And these two things further
guarantee the creation of human benefit which is the basic goal of Islam or maqashid
al-shari'ah.
In
the second observation, a case was found where a couple whose husband had a
mental disability was caused by aridhi's disability (caused by an accident).
CONCLUSION
Based on exposure above, then study on "Criticism of Islamic Law
against Law No. 8 of 2016 concerning Disabilities about Marriage Mental
Disabilities�, can concluded as following: By general religion of Islam is not
once forbid the marriage that took place between disabled mentally handicapped
p this remember the goal base marriage that is as means distribute desire
sexual with good and true as well as as institution
preventive happening wickedness and adultery. Although thus, in order to
achieve family sakinah, mawaddah
and rahmah, Islam recommends exists mental maturity
for those who want married. With exists this mental maturity expected no will
arise disaster as the purpose of Allah SWT is to preach the law . See
characteristics from types disabled mentally
handicapped, then that is permissible for marry just disabled type light,
meanwhile disabled with IQ level below 50 preferably held prevention marriage.
this remember that disabled with an IQ below 50 have big dependency to others
meanwhile disabled disabled type light with an IQ
between 50-70 still capable educate.
In Law No. 8 of 2106 concerning Persons Disabilities for disabled
mentally disabled _ law marriage permanent legitimate in facet legal and not
must exists cancellation in facet condition marriage. Because for disabled good
mentally disabled that candidate bride Men or woman no there is criteria must
mentally healthy.
Fulfillment obligation wife disabled true mental disability no perfect
if must be adjusted with fulfillment obligation wife normally . Because of him
could called the affected person burden law and under forgiveness . But because
he stay together family big and in in category mild
mental disabilities that can be taught so fulfillment obligation wife by the
disabled perspective mental disability law Islam no occur many to meaningful
trouble, though _ Duty house the stairs should be Becomes obligation wife no
could fulfilled with good and must replaced by a
guardian or another family.
In house household, husband and wife is have equal roles, mutual help help in realize house ladder sakinah
who is blessed by Allah SWT. Joy and sorrow in journey wedding is part not inseparable in wade ark house stairs, so if
later day occur things that don't wanted like condition husband or wife experience
mentally handicapped or because other, then each partner to remember return
destination marriage and no make divorce as option beginning for complete
problem. because that, Islam forbids exists the deed to be threaten bond holy
marriage, as well as for those who consider trivial existence. Because of deeds
such (divorce) can remove goodness and benefit for husband Wife especially if
conducted with arbitrary.
REFERENCES
Abdullah, AG (1994). Introduction to Compilation of Islamic Law in
Indonesian Legal System . Human Echo.
al-Ja'fi, A. -B. (1991). al-Imam Abi Abdillah Muhammad Ibn
Ismail Ibn Ibrahim Ibn al-Mughirah Ibn Bardazbah. Sahih Al-Bukharuy. Beirut:
Compact Disc Hadith. Edition , 1996 .
Al-San'ani, M. bin I. (1999). Subul al-Salam Sharh Bulugh
al-Maram Min JamAdilla al-Ahkam. Dar Al-Kitab Al-'Arabi, Beirut .
Azhar, BA (2004). Indonesian Marriage Law .
Yogyakarta: UII Press.
Aziz, AW (2021). Annisa's commentary methodology by M.
Rahmat Najieb . UIN Sunan Ampel Surabaya.
Bardizbah, I. (nd). Al Imam Abi Abdillah Muhammad Ibn Ismail
Ibn Ibrahim Ibn Mughiroh. 1994. Shohih Al Bukhari Volume , 1 .
Basuki, S. (2006). Research Methods, Jakarta. Wedatama
Widya Sastra .
bin Hajjaj Alqusyairi, AHM (nd). An-Naisaburi, Sahih Muslim,
Book. Al-Masaajid Wa Mawaadhi'us Shalaah, Juz , 1 .
Dawud, A. (1984). Sunan Abu Dawud (Vol. 1). Sh.
Muhammad Ashraf.
Efendi, M. (2005). Introduction to Psychopedagogic .
Malang: The Literary Land.
Hawari, D. (1997). Al Qur'an science of mental medicine
and mental health .
Kartono, K. (2009). Abnormal Psychology and Sex
Abnormalities. Bandung: CV. Mandar Madju .
Khallaf, AW (2003). The Science of Ushul Fiqh (Islamic Rules
of Law). Translated by Faiz El Muttaqin, Jakarta: Amani Library .
Muchtar, K. (2016). Principles of Islamic Law Concerning
Marriage, Jakarta: Crescent Star. Moch. Isnaeni .
Mughniyah, J. (2004). Muhammad, Fiqh of the Five Schools,
trans. Masykur Ab, et al, Jakarta: Lanterns .
Muhtar, F. (n.d.). Thanks.
Rispler-Chaim, V. (2006). Disabilities in Islamic law (Vol.
32). Springer Science & Business Media.
Rofiq, AC (2017). Islamic History of the Classical Period .
Gunung Samudera Publisher [PT Book Mart Indonesia Publishing Group].
Saekan, & Effendi, E. (1997). History of Compilation
of Islamic Law Compilation in Indonesia . Arkola.
Selway, D., & Ashman, AF (1998). Disability, religion and
health: A literature review in search of the spiritual dimensions of
disability. Disabilities & Society , 13 (3), 429�439.
Somantri, GR (2005). Understand qualitative methods. Makara
Human Behavior Studies in Asia , 9 (2), 57�65.
Summa, MA (2004). Islamic family law in the Islamic world .
RajaGrafindo Persada.
Syafe, R. (2007). I, Usul Fiqh Sciences . Bandung:
Faithful Library.
Shah, IM (1992). Philosophy of Islamic Law . Jakarta:
Earth Script.
Yahya, M., & Rahman, F. (1979). The basics of
fostering fiqh-Islamy law . Sa'adiyah Putra.
Zuhudi, M. (2019). The legal status of marriage for persons
with mental disabilities in the view of Imam Syafi'i and its relevance to the
Law on Marriage No. 1 of 1974. Walisongo State Islamic University .